Free Tool

Should I grade my card?

Updated November 15, 2026

Whether it's PSA, BGS, SGC or CGC, grading pays off only when a good grade is likely and worth a lot more than the raw card. Enter your numbers and this calculator weighs both outcomes.

What the ungraded card sells for today.

Grading fee plus shipping and insurance both ways. Check the grader's current prices.

The grade you're hoping for, e.g. a PSA 9.

One step down, e.g. a PSA 8. Blank = same as raw.

An estimate from your own numbers, not a prediction of any grade. Selling fees and time to sell aren't included.

How the calculator decides

Grading has two possible results, and the calculator prices both. If the card comes back in the grade you hoped for, you gain the graded price minus what you paid to grade it and the raw card you gave up. If it comes back a step lower, you get the lower graded price instead, which is often close to the raw value, so the fee is lost.

expected gain = (chance × good-grade price) + ((1 − chance) × lower-grade price) − raw value − grading cost

It says Grade it when the expected gain is positive and worth the trouble (at least $10 and a quarter of the raw value), Toss-up when it's only slightly positive, and Don't grade when you'd expect to lose money.

What grading really costs

The grading fee is only part of it. Count all of these per card:

When grading usually pays off

When to keep it raw

Check the condition before you send it

Look at the card under a bright light, ideally with a magnifier, and tilt it to catch the surface.

If you find anything, pick "Unlikely" in the calculator and see whether grading still makes sense.

Where to find the numbers

The best inputs are recent sold prices for your exact card: same year, set, card number and parallel. Asking prices, what sellers are listing a card for right now, usually run higher than what cards actually sell for, so using them makes grading look better than it is.

Card Detective identifies the card from a photo and shows what sellers are asking for it today, raw and as a PSA 9, so you have a starting point in seconds. Pro also shows asking prices across grades.

Not sure what your card is?

Snap a photo and Card Detective identifies it and shows current asking prices. 10 free scans a month, no account needed.

Download on the App Store

Questions

Is it worth grading a card worth less than $20?

Usually not. Once you add the grading fee and shipping and insurance both ways, a low-value card has to jump a lot in value just to break even, and a mid grade often sells for about the same as the raw card. The exceptions are cards whose top grades sell for many times the raw price.

Does grading always increase a card's value?

No. Grading adds value when the card comes back in a high grade that buyers pay extra for. A lower grade can be worth the same as the raw card, or less once fees are counted, because the flaws are now printed on the label.

Which prices should I use in the calculator?

Use recent sold prices for the same card where you can find them. Asking prices, what sellers list cards for, usually run higher than what cards actually sell for, so they make grading look better than it is. Card Detective shows current asking prices, including a PSA 9 benchmark, as a starting point.

How do I know if my card will get a high grade?

Check four things under good light: centering (are the borders even on all sides?), corners (sharp, no white or rounding), edges (no chipping or whitening) and surface (no scratches, print lines, dents or stains). A single visible flaw usually rules out the top grades.