How the calculator decides
Grading has two possible results, and the calculator prices both. If the card comes back in the grade you hoped for, you gain the graded price minus what you paid to grade it and the raw card you gave up. If it comes back a step lower, you get the lower graded price instead, which is often close to the raw value, so the fee is lost.
It says Grade it when the expected gain is positive and worth the trouble (at least $10 and a quarter of the raw value), Toss-up when it's only slightly positive, and Don't grade when you'd expect to lose money.
What grading really costs
The grading fee is only part of it. Count all of these per card:
- The grading fee, which depends on the service level and, at most companies, on the card's declared value. Higher-value cards cost more to grade.
- Shipping and insurance both ways. Sending one card at a time makes this a big share of the cost; it's cheaper per card in a batch.
- Supplies: card savers or semi-rigid holders and a sturdy box.
- Time. Turnaround can run from weeks to months at the cheapest service levels, and prices can move while you wait.
When grading usually pays off
- The card is in near-perfect condition and the top grades sell for several times the raw price.
- Key rookie cards and popular players or characters, where buyers specifically look for graded copies.
- Older cards in unusually good condition, because few survived that way.
- You plan to sell, and buyers of that card pay more for a slab they can trust.
When to keep it raw
- The raw card is worth less than the grading cost. Even a strong grade rarely rescues it.
- You can see a flaw: a soft corner, whitening on the edges, a scratch, or uneven borders.
- Graded copies of that card are plentiful and sell for little more than raw ones.
- You're keeping it for yourself and don't need the label.
Check the condition before you send it
Look at the card under a bright light, ideally with a magnifier, and tilt it to catch the surface.
- Centering: compare the borders left to right and top to bottom, front and back.
- Corners: all four should be sharp, with no white showing and no rounding.
- Edges: no chipping or white specks, especially on dark borders.
- Surface: no scratches, print lines, dents, creases or stains. Shiny cards hide scratches until you tilt them.
If you find anything, pick "Unlikely" in the calculator and see whether grading still makes sense.
Where to find the numbers
The best inputs are recent sold prices for your exact card: same year, set, card number and parallel. Asking prices, what sellers are listing a card for right now, usually run higher than what cards actually sell for, so using them makes grading look better than it is.
Card Detective identifies the card from a photo and shows what sellers are asking for it today, raw and as a PSA 9, so you have a starting point in seconds. Pro also shows asking prices across grades.